Prefect has become a popular choice for orchestrating data workflows, but it's not the only option out there. As the data engineering landscape continues to evolve, new alternatives emerge that offer unique features and advantages tailored to different needs. In this blog post, we'll explore some of the top Prefect alternatives, delving into their strengths, weaknesses, and how they can help you create and manage data pipelines more efficiently. Stay tuned to discover which option might be the perfect fit for your data engineering requirements!
Mage
Mage is designed to empower data teams by seamlessly integrating and synchronizing data from third-party sources, constructing real-time and batch pipelines using Python, SQL, and R, as well as effectively running, monitoring, and orchestrating numerous pipelines. The platform provides a user-friendly developer experience, allowing users to develop either locally or in the cloud utilizing Terraform and offering a selection of programming languages for added flexibility. Mage incorporates engineering best practices, featuring modular code with data validations, which replaces conventional DAGs with tangled code.
With Mage's preview functionality, users receive immediate feedback via an interactive notebook UI, and data is treated as a top-priority element by versioning, partitioning, and cataloging data generated in the pipeline. The platform also enables cloud-based collaborative development, version control using Git, and testing without the need for shared staging environments. Deploying to AWS, GCP, or Azure is simplified with well-maintained Terraform templates, and scaling is streamlined with in-data warehouse transformations or native Spark integration. Ultimately, Mage provides integrated monitoring, alerting, and observability through a user-friendly interface, making it easy for smaller teams to manage and scale thousands of pipelines which makes Mage a great Prefect alternative.
Check out Mage:
Dagster
Dagster, a data orchestration platform, provides a unified view for data teams to monitor, fine-tune, and troubleshoot intricate data workflows. It caters to data professionals who prefer a software engineering-centric approach to data pipelines. Notable features include a productivity platform for defining software-driven assets, a powerful orchestration engine with adaptable architecture, and a cohesive control plane for centralizing metadata. In contrast to Apache Airflow, Dagster emphasizes an asset-based orchestration method, focusing on data asset dependencies, which results in improved productivity, error detection, and scalability from a personal laptop to a multi-tenant business platform.
Dagster sets itself apart by decoupling IO and resources from the DAG logic, making local testing more straightforward than Airflow. The platform also encourages continuous integration, code reviews, staging environments, and debugging. However, its cloud solution pricing model can be complex, with varying billing rates per minute of compute time. While an open-source version is accessible on GitHub, it presents a challenging learning curve. Dagster is ideally suited for data-centric practitioners with a background in data engineering, delivering an all-encompassing solution for creating and deploying data applications.
Check out Dagster:
Luigi
Luigi, a Python package created for extended batch processing, offers a structure for developing and overseeing data processing pipelines. Originating from Spotify, it allows for automated execution of data processing tasks across multiple objects in a batch. Its main features encompass modularity, extensibility, scalability, and a technology-agnostic design. Luigi facilitates the integration of various tasks, such as Hive queries, Hadoop jobs, and Spark jobs, into a unified pipeline. It is most fitting for backend developers who aim to automate intricate data flows using a Python-oriented solution.
Although Luigi features an instinctive architecture and streamlines the process of restarting failed pipelines, it has certain drawbacks. Creating task dependencies can be complicated, and it does not offer distributed execution, making it better suited for smaller to mid-sized data jobs. Additionally, some features are restricted to Unix systems, and it does not accommodate real-time workflows or event-triggered workflows, depending on cron jobs for scheduling. Despite these limitations, Luigi remains a useful instrument for managing and automating data processing tasks as an alternative to Prefect.
Check out Luigi:
Apache Airflow
Apache Airflow is an open-source platform for workflow management and scheduling. It allows users to programmatically author, schedule, and monitor data pipelines using Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs). DAGs are a collection of tasks with dependencies that define the execution order, ensuring that tasks are executed in the correct sequence. Airflow is written in Python, making it easy for developers to create custom tasks, operators, and workflows using familiar programming concepts.
Airflow is widely used by data engineers and teams to automate and orchestrate complex data processing workflows, enabling efficient handling of data extraction, transformation, and loading (ETL) processes. The platform offers a variety of built-in integrations with popular data processing tools and platforms, such as Apache Spark, Hadoop, and various cloud services, making it a powerful and flexible solution for managing large-scale data workflows.
Check out Airflow:
Azure Data Factory
Azure Data Factory, a fully managed and serverless data integration service, is tailored for data teams in search of a serverless option that strongly integrates with Microsoft-specific solutions such as Azure Blob Storage and Microsoft SQL Server. The platform highlights no-code pipeline components, providing a means to rehost SQL Server Integration Services (SSIS) and construct ETL/ELT pipelines with embedded Git and CI/CD without coding. This pay-as-you-go, entirely managed serverless cloud service scales according to demand, delivering flexibility and cost-efficiency.
With over 90 built-in connectors, Azure Data Factory enables ingestion of on-premises and software-as-a-service (SaaS) data, supporting orchestration and monitoring at scale. Furthermore, the platform offers robust integrations with the wider Microsoft Azure platform, making it an optimal choice for those already using Azure services or seeking seamless interoperability with Microsoft solutions.
Check out Azure Data Factory:
Shipyard
Shipyard presents a comprehensive platform loaded with features aimed at streamlining the development and experimentation of new business solutions. Essential elements include organizational projects, integrated notifications and error-handling, automated scheduling, triggers on demand, and the absence of proprietary code configuration. Additionally, the platform offers shareable and reusable blueprints, isolated resources that scale for each solution, and extensive historical logging, promoting smooth collaboration and effective resource management.
These features are further enhanced by a user-friendly UI for effortless management and comprehensive admin controls and permissions, granting users considerable control over their projects. In summary, Shipyard delivers an all-inclusive and intuitive environment for efficiently creating and implementing cutting-edge business solutions.
Check out Shipyard:
As you can see, there are many options that you can pick as an alternative to Prefect. We may be a little biased here at Shipyard, but we think you'll like using our platform based on its ease of use and ability to get things up and running quickly. If you'd like to discuss orchestration for your organization, grab some time with our team. We would love to discuss how orchestration can help your data team.
