While Apache Airflow is a popular platform for managing complex data workflows, it has its fair share of disadvantages that have led users to seek alternatives. Some of the most common complaints among both technical professionals and business representatives include insufficient documentation, a challenging learning curve, and the complexity of production setup and maintenance. In this blog post, we'll explore Airflow alternatives that address these concerns, providing a more user-friendly and efficient workflow management experience.
Prefect is a data flow automation platform that is designed for data engineers who are in search of a solution to Airflow's development challenges. The platform allows users to orchestrate Python code using its Orion engine, which supports type annotations, async support, and first-class functions. Prefect's UI lets you set up notifications, schedule workflows and view run history, while its OSS's orchestration and execution layers can be managed independently. Moreover, the software blends the ease of the Cloud with the security of on-premises, enabling businesses to deploy, monitor and manage processes more efficiently. Its library includes predefined tasks that facilitate the running of shell scripts, managing Kubernetes jobs, and sending tweets. Prefect is also supported by a robust community of Engineers and Data Scientists.
The platform eliminates negative engineering by offering an easy-to-deploy orchestration layer for the current data stack. As a result, users can effectively quadruple their output, allowing data specialists and scientists to manage their workflows and data pipelines more efficiently. The software also supports parallelization and scaling using Kubernetes and event-driven workflows. However, its limited free tier and difficult deployment of the self-service solution may be challenging for some users. In summary, Prefect is suitable for enterprise users as an alternative to Airflow who require a pricier yet managed workflow orchestrator.
Check out Prefect:
Dagster, a data orchestration tool, offers a single plane of glass for data teams to observe, optimize, and debug complex data workflows. It is designed for data professionals who prefer a software engineering-oriented approach to data pipelines. Key features include a productivity platform for defining software-defined assets, a robust orchestration engine with flexible architecture, and a unified control plane for centralizing metadata. Compared to Apache Airflow, Dagster takes an asset-based approach to orchestration, focusing on data asset dependencies. This enables increased productivity, error detection, and a scalable orchestration environment from a laptop to a multi-tenant business platform.
Dagster differentiates itself by separating IO and resources from the DAG logic, making it easier to test locally than Airflow. It also promotes continuous integration, code reviews, staging environments, and debugging. However, it has a convoluted pricing model for its cloud solution, with different billing rates per minute of compute time. An open-source version is available on GitHub, but it comes with a steep learning curve. Dagster is best suited as an Airflow alternative for data-focused practitioners with experience in data engineering, offering a comprehensive solution for developing and deploying data applications.
Check out Dagster:
Azure Data Factory
Azure Data Factory is a fully managed, serverless data integration service designed for data teams seeking a serverless solution with robust integration with Microsoft-specific solutions like Azure Blob Storage or Microsoft SQL Server. It emphasizes no-code pipeline components, offering a platform to rehost SQL Server Integration Services (SSIS) and build ETL/ELT pipelines with built-in Git and CI/CD without writing any code. As a pay-as-you-go, fully managed serverless cloud service, it scales on demand, providing flexibility and cost-effectiveness.
Azure Data Factory boasts more than 90 built-in connectors for ingesting on-premises and software-as-a-service (SaaS) data, facilitating orchestration and monitoring at scale. Additionally, it features strong integrations with the broader Microsoft Azure platform, making it an ideal choice as an alternative to Airflow for those already utilizing Azure services or seeking seamless compatibility with Microsoft solutions.
Check out Azure Data Factory:
Luigi is a Python package designed for long-running batch processing, providing a framework for creating and managing data processing pipelines. Developed by Spotify, it enables the automatic execution of data processing tasks on several objects in a batch. Key features include modularity, extensibility, scalability, and technology-agnostic design. Luigi can be used to stitch together various tasks, such as Hive queries, Hadoop jobs, and Spark jobs, into a cohesive pipeline. It is best suited for backend developers automating complex data flows with a Python-like solution.
While Luigi boasts an intuitive architecture and simplifies restarting failed pipelines, it has some limitations. Designing task dependencies can be challenging, and it lacks distributed execution capabilities, making it more appropriate for small to mid-sized data jobs. Furthermore, certain features are exclusive to Unix systems, and it does not support real-time workflows or event-triggered workflows, relying on cron jobs for scheduling. Despite these drawbacks, Luigi remains a valuable tool for managing and automating data processing tasks.
Check out Luigi:
Mage is designed to give data teams magical powers by integrating and synchronizing data from third-party sources, building real-time and batch pipelines using Python, SQL, and R, and running, monitoring, and orchestrating thousands of pipelines efficiently. The platform offers an easy developer experience, enabling users to develop locally or in the cloud using Terraform, with a choice of programming languages for flexibility. Mage's engineering best practices include modular code with data validations, replacing traditional DAGs with spaghetti code.
Mage's preview feature provides instant feedback with an interactive notebook UI, treating data as a first-class citizen by versioning, partitioning, and cataloging data produced in the pipeline. It also supports collaborative cloud-based development, version control with Git, and testing without waiting for shared staging environments. Deployment to AWS, GCP, or Azure is made simple with maintained Terraform templates, and scaling is effortless with direct data warehouse transformations or native Spark integration. Finally, Mage offers built-in monitoring, alerting, and observability through an intuitive user interface, making it easy for small teams to manage and scale thousands of pipelines.
Check out Mage:
Shipyard offers a feature-rich platform designed to simplify the process of launching and experimenting with new business solutions. Key aspects include projects for organization, built-in notifications and error-handling, automatic scheduling, on-demand triggers, and no proprietary code configuration. The platform also provides sharable, reusable blueprints, isolated scaling resources for each solution, and detailed historical logging, facilitating seamless collaboration and efficient resource management.
Complementing these features is a streamlined UI for easy management and in-depth admin controls and permissions, enabling users to maintain a high level of control over their projects. Overall, Shipyard provides a comprehensive and user-friendly environment for developing and deploying innovative business solutions with ease and efficiency.
Check out Shipyard:
There are various alternatives to Airflow, and each one offers different benefits. At Shipyard, we believe our platform stands out for its intuitive design and fast implementation. While we may be partial to our own solution, we understand that each organization has unique needs and requirements. We encourage you to explore your options and determine which platform is the best fit for your team's goals and workflows.
If you're interested in learning more about data orchestration and how it can benefit your organization, our team is available to discuss. We are passionate about helping data teams succeed and would be happy to chat with you about your specific needs and challenges. Don't hesitate to schedule a call with us to learn more about how orchestration can streamline your data workflows.